06/22/2007, 10:32 AM

Industry/General

Chinese sedan flunks German crash test (with video)

Jiangling Motor’s Landwind X6 SUV made headlines in 2005 when it received a score of zero in a German crash test. If the results of crash tests conducted this week by Germany’s ADAC are any indication, Chinese automakers haven’t made much progress when it comes to safety.

The Brilliance BS6 sedan scored one out of a possible five stars. “The BS6 sedan performed almost as badly as the Landwind,” ADAC spokesman Maximilian Maurer told the AFP.

“After Landwind’s 2005 test result, it stopped being sold in Europe,” he said. The BS6 could face the same fate.

The ADAC said a person would probably not survive a crash in the BS6 at 64 km/h.

For comparison purposes, below is a video of BMW’s 3-Series undergoing a similar test:

 
 

06/22, 11:17 AM

posted by:

SRT-4Ken

=============>>and keep in mind folks, 64km/h is exactly 35mph, not 45….as bad as that car did, u would think it was a 60mph frontal crash, seriously….i walked on the highway after work one night of a ‘95 honda accord hit an ‘03 Chevy Z71 head on at 55mph and the honda had no cabin damage at all besides the windshield and the lady got out without a scratch…..i’ll remind myself again, that test was only 35mph….eewwww

06/22, 11:19 AM

posted by:

Syrax

there’s a little room for improvement…

06/22, 11:49 AM

posted by:

global_lightning

A couple of months ago I was at a conference in Panama. We were pick up from the airport in these Chinese 10 passenger vans. The doors were less than an inch thick; I nearly bent one just closing it. On the road the thing squeeked like a rubber ducky and every pothole sent the suspension into a jello wiggle. It felt unsafe at 15 MPH, let alone highway speeds. I’m sure it got rediculous fuel economy but there is only so much you can sacrifice…

06/22, 11:50 AM

posted by:

global_lightning

Also, am I the only who who saw ‘Jiangling’ and read it as ‘Jing-a-ling’?

06/22, 11:58 AM

posted by:

supakali

Chinese automakers have ALOT to catch up.
Safety? how about handling? performance? reliability? warranty?
And they rip off the designs like its all good.
Thank God no chinese automobiles are available in US.

06/22, 11:58 AM

posted by:

buenos

With growing objections to the Chinese “one child” rule, maybe this is the new way of trying to control the Chinese population.

06/22, 12:00 PM

posted by:

Mitch Bangowitz

I look at those gore websites sometimes and I swear whenever there’s a car crash in China with an obviously Chinese made Passat or Accord, the car is split in two…. with dead Chinese people lying here and there.

I think they must make the Passats and Accords there to their own standards …which are low…. to save money… cut a little here… cut a little there. Why else would these Passats and Accords be split in half in almost every crash?

Now with all the poisened food and medicine coming out of China and we keep rewarding China with more and more business.

The other day I saw household products made in New Zealand… I was so excited at the prospect of buying something made in a country that doesn’t treat it’s people like garbage that I bought a bunch of the items even though it was expensive!

06/22, 12:36 PM

posted by:

Blakkarr

“You are not ready…” -SONY

06/22, 12:43 PM

posted by:

CTS DRIVER

new zeland…..yes, now there is a country i dont mind supporting.

06/22, 12:54 PM

posted by:

1c3d0g

Buenos: LMAO! :D

06/22, 1:22 PM

posted by:

2008PowerStrokeF450Lariat

well, ill just stick to my american vehicles thank you very much

06/22, 1:32 PM

posted by:

Fromes

it doesn’t matter how cheap they can sell these things for, if it isnt safe, no one will buy it. All the chinese cars look like ripoffs of other company’s cars. Those accords you were talking about crashing in china prob were not accords at all, just some vehicle resembling one. I saw a picture of a chinese SUV, it was a pontiac torrent front and a RX330 rear, im suprised they dont get sued.

06/22, 1:53 PM

posted by:

robwilliams

It will be back to the drawing boards for the Chinese Engineers. They obviously haven’t learnt anything about safety cells from making bamboo bicycles!

06/22, 2:08 PM

posted by:

Aston Martin

SEE, THE BMW WAS BEST.
THEN AGAIN, THE CHINESE SHOULDN’T MAKE CARS. THEY DON’T SEEM TO BE VERY GOOD AT SLIGHTLY MORE SKILFUL JOBS, DO THEY.
GREAT WORK ON YOUR BIG WALL, THOUGH CHINA. KEEP UP THE GOOD WORK WITH PREETY MUCH ALL THE OTHER STUFF THAT YOU MAKE.

06/22, 2:11 PM

posted by:

gbb

WOW, what a cheap piece of ****!

But then again, I have that same opinion of all Asian cars.

Folded up like a $2 umbrella in a Kansas tornado.

06/22, 2:29 PM

posted by:

LP640

China shouldnt even dream or hope about making cars bcause they will just be terrible and have a sticker that says Made In China. They should just get back to working on sweatshops and on farms producing our food for us.

06/22, 2:37 PM

posted by:

gitcypher

Ha Jing-a-ling
You beat me to it global_lightning

06/22, 3:34 PM

posted by:

sharpie

Poison food is not news, at least not in China! I heard about it all the time back home and I am from HK. We do not buy Chinese made food product even though they are cheaper than those made and packaged in HK. The quality control is non-existent!

A friend of mine went to Shenzhen and bought a jump drive when they were still relatively expensive. The thing did not work so he opened it up to find the end of a USB plug inside with about half on inch of the cord still attached.

Last year I went to NAIAS aka Detroit Autoshow. There was one Chinese automaker in the show in the lower floor, and rightfully so because the show car had paint chips in the paperthin paint. Chinese cars, or joint ventured cars made in China are just unsafe. I hate visiting my relatives because of the death traps on wheels.

06/22, 4:14 PM

posted by:

Masher

I wonder how many decades you’d have to go backwards to find a japanese, german or american car that dangerous in a minor accident.

06/22, 4:20 PM

posted by:

CTS DRIVER

masher probably back to the model t

06/22, 5:41 PM

posted by:

jonnycat

They should let Michael Bryant have one

06/22, 7:20 PM

posted by:

RicardoHead

30 years ago almost every car in the world fared as badly in tests.
15 years ago a Hyundai was a laughing stock of a car company.
5 years ago I wouldn’t buy one tool made in China - today there are a quite a few I’d consider.
10 years from now Chinese made cars will probably comprise 500,000 unit sales in the USA and they will be as generally safe as any.
.
People like you discounted all of post-war Germany for “100 years to come”, said the Japanese in the 1960s and early 1970s were only good for transistor radios, cheap toys, and crappy “japtraps”, and laughed at Hyundai in 1990. Laugh at the Chinese all you want today - I guarantee they are laughing back … all the way to the bank.

06/22, 8:37 PM

posted by:

Arbiter

Wal Mart will sell them…….and the scary thing is morons will buy them!

Forty years ago we thought China would go to war with us, today they don’t need to, they have invaded us one shipping container at a time and bought up our national debt!

But we will prevail, Mickey D’s and KFC will clog their ateries and they will grow fat and complacent! The power of culture will always beat the army! Of course by then we will all be dead, but hey, you gotta sacrifice!

06/22, 9:46 PM

posted by:

LP640

========================>^Look a little closer to home Arbiter you blind bastard its the Americans who are dying from clogged up arteries after having one too many KFC’s and Mickey D’s NOT the chinese you ignorant pig. Even though this toy car may be a pathetic excuse for a mode of transportation im sure that some mentally retarded morons named Bob and Sue would be more than happy to drive one of thses deathtraps which i suspect would crumble into dust after collididng witha child’s bicycle. I think RicardoHead might be right about the part of the chinese laughing all the way to their piggy banks.

06/22, 9:47 PM

posted by:

global_lightning

Holy s**t! An empty beer can has better crash resistance!
On the other hand, Ford is shopping Volvo around, and I bet Jiangling has got the cash…

06/22, 10:26 PM

posted by:

55amg

by the way, i think these cars probably got 5/5 in the “Chinese” crash test.

06/22, 10:47 PM

posted by:

nickthaskater

“and keep in mind folks, 64km/h is exactly 35mph,” - SRT4-Ken

No it isn’t, it’s 39.767 756 303 mph -exactly-.

06/22, 11:12 PM

posted by:

GMCsyclone#478

LP640, maybe “Bob and Sue” (slur?) would buy chinese death traps, but not because they are “mentally retarded morons”. unscrupulous chinese profiteers will produce and sell dirt cheap products, while unscrupulous americans will slyly market and sell them at a considerable profit.

i too believe the chinese are laughing all the way to the bank, but why does that lead you to pick on the victims (“Bob and Sue”) rather than those exploiting them (in addition to an untold number of child-aged slaves).

the chinese know very well the crap they are producing and selling to americans and other countries, with seemingly no principles. quality control and regulations are virtually NON-EXISTENT in china (or just not enforced).

it is very difficult to buy non-chinese made products, even though you might be aware of the threat. too many products that are ‘Made’ in trusted nations have components or ingredients straight out of china - yet there is no way for the consumer to know.

it seems to me that the answer lies in each of us, whenever possible, not buying products made, marketed or sold in such a manner (e.g. chinese products). choke the profit out of the unscrupulous profiteers.

06/23, 8:43 AM

posted by:

CTS DRIVER

by the way, i think these cars probably got 5/5 in the “Chinese” crash test.

Comment by 55amg, posted on June22 at 10:26 pm

hahahaha, good one, lmao.

06/23, 4:06 PM

posted by:

04focus

On the other hand, the Chinese gained one star in two years. at this rate they’ll make cars that have 5-star crash ratings by 2015….

06/23, 5:11 PM

posted by:

illwill

LMFAO

06/24, 2:03 AM

posted by:

Ian

well now… I feel MUCH safer in my Ford Taurus lol

06/24, 6:12 AM

posted by:

GBilbo070

i know what id rather buy.

06/24, 10:23 AM

posted by:

RicardoHead

I remember a friend’s Civic (1st or 2nd generation, I think) which was something like a 1979 or 1980 car. The lower rear seat was held in place with ….. velcro. You got it, velcro. Not bolts or screws, but velcro. This wasn’t some prior-owner half-assed rigged BS because his parents owned it new.
.
That was Honda then, and you know what Honda is now. In fact that was Honda in 1980 and we all know what Honda was in 1990. Don’t discount “Jing-a-Ling” or Ding-a-Ling or Cherry or any Chinese company so quickly, folks. You’d be very very stupid to do so.

06/24, 11:12 AM

posted by:

55amg

but the Chinese and Japanese are different. I think that if you crashed that civic at 40mph you wouldn’t die.

06/24, 2:30 PM

posted by:

SRT-4Ken

============>>very good thinkin indeed, 55amg….you beat me to that statement….

06/24, 4:29 PM

posted by:

RicardoHead

Don’t know about that, 55amg. I think if you crashed a 1980 civic at 40mph into a brick wall it would have crumpled as much or more as that “Brilliance” from China. Yes, there are 25 years inbetween, but this is China’s first real foray into building a car for a competitive modern international market. Truth is almost every one of these “3rd world upstarts” from major economies that sticks with it ends up producing world class products within a reasonable timeframe, and the Chinese will be no different. If anything the insular (import-restricted) nature of China’s domestic automotive market which secures direct foreign investment to produce products to western standards forces their local companies to compete with international products very quickly, and provides an excellent base of learning/copying technology. As I said before … laugh all you want, but in 10 years autos from China will comprise 500,000 unit sales here, almost guranteed. In 20 years it’ll be well over a million.

06/24, 6:32 PM

posted by:

A4

CHINA SUCKS seriously, i think i was one of the only ones who said that back when the dodge hornet articles were around on LLN, everyone called us naysayers ignorant and stupid, now look who the ignorant ones were.

06/24, 6:32 PM

posted by:

A4

ricardohead - chinese autos wont be here in 10 years with this kind of crash test ratings.

06/24, 9:29 PM

posted by:

SRT-4Ken

==========>>tell me about it, A4….

06/25, 4:40 AM

posted by:

fan

dont forget, the chinese are coming. they got (nearly) unlimited resources, and a REALLY strong will to be amongst the top nations in the world - in ANY aspect.
maybe this first cars flunk badly. they WILL learn, imrpove their designs (yes, they will copy… but as long as people get the lowest price product, not the most genuine design, that wont bother them)..

ridiculing them is no help…

06/25, 8:49 AM

posted by:

deantj

sucky sucky! Me love you long time!

06/25, 9:20 AM

posted by:

maximus

The only star this one gets is a yellow star on a big red flag. Come to think of it, that’s China’s flag!!!

06/25, 9:46 AM

posted by:

Arbiter

LP640,
I may well be a “blind bastard AND an ignorant pig” but if you will take the time to learn to read, you will see that I am saying as we export our fast food culture to China (which the Chinese are eager to embrace) THEY will become the fat and lazy.

Our effects on other cultures via popular culture is way more powerful than military action.

And don’t talk about Bob and Sue that way, it is wrong to insult your parents in such a manner…………

06/25, 1:25 PM

posted by:

CTS DRIVER

that thing broke like a fortune cookie, “confucious say:youre dead”

06/25, 2:29 PM

posted by:

Get Real

More work for “crash test dummies”, i.e: prison labor.

“We execute you now, or you test crash this car.”

What a great communist system.

Anyone remember China is a communist country where the party line is what you speak, all the time. Or you do jail time.

Now crash test this car.

06/25, 8:04 PM

posted by:

ml350pc

I go out of my way (and wallet) to not buy stuff that is made in China, and in most instances have been successful in that mission. Having said that, I would not buy a Chineese car if someone gave me the money. When it comes to safety, I will stick with my 2006 Envoy XL. I had an earlier model invlved in a crash with a 24 foot box truck, and that vehicle maintained its original dimensions.

06/26, 9:04 AM

posted by:

CarStar

Is Dodge still going to let Chery manufacture the
Hornet??? They should think twice…

06/26, 7:28 PM

posted by:

Vertical

pretty damn funny, CTS!

China probably will improve, as some of you have said. But hopefully the bad news coming out of that country lately (dead pets, “dead” crash test dummies), just MAYBE some of our greedy corporate types will slow down outsourcing to China.

06/28, 12:30 PM

posted by:

56oval

I can’t wait to buy my Ex-wife one of these.

07/02, 12:36 AM

posted by:

sharpie

“10 years from now Chinese made cars will probably comprise 500,000 unit sales in the USA and they will be as generally safe as any.”

WOW, don’t give up your day-job for fortune-telling because you suck at it!

 
 
You need to log in with your user name and password before you can leave comments.

    

Forgot your Password?

Don't have a user name yet? Simply fill in the form below and click the link provided in the
confirmation email. You must supply a valid email address to complete the registration process.

  
 
 
 
  • Login
  • About
  • Contact
Please note that you need to log in with your user name and password before you can leave comments.
  

login
cancel
Forgot your Password?
Don't have a user name yet? Click here to register now.

Simply fill in the form below and click the link provided in the confirmation email. You must supply a valid email address to complete the registration process.

  
submit
cancel
Leftlane is the leading source for automotive industry and vehicle news, new car research, future vehicle information, and reviews. Read by car shoppers, driving enthusiasts, autoworkers, executives, and investors, the website is updated throughout the day with the very latest auto news - as it happens.

Leftlane also provides consumers with accurate and media-rich information on every car currently on the market. In-market shoppers can review specs, read overviews, view high-resolution images, watch videos, and estimate pricing. No other automotive publication brings together the same degree of timeliness, thoroughness and accuracy as Leftlane.
 
submit
cancel