NEW FUTURE MARKET
  • Consumer Reports names Porsche 911 best sports car

    By admin

    In Consumer Reports‘ first-ever tests of ultra-performance and luxury sports cars, the Porsche 911 edged past the Corvette Z06 to become the top-rated vehicle with an “Excellent” overall score. The 911 was tested against two other ultra-performance cars, the Z06 and the V10-powered Dodge Viper, for the October issue of the magazine. The Z06 also earned an “Excellent” score while the Viper posted a “Very Good” score. The magazine also tested five high-end, luxury sports cars: the Mercedes-Benz SL550, BMW 650i, Jaguar XK, Cadillac XLR, and Lexus SC. The SL550 and BMW 650i coupe posted the highest overall scores among those vehicles. This is the most expensive monthly test group ever purchased by Consumer Reports, costing in excess of $650,000.

    Consumers Union, the publisher of Consumer Reports, says accepts no outside advertising, no free test samples, and has no agenda other than the interests of the consumer.

    “The 911 wowed us enough with its acceleration, handling, and braking for us to rate it our top sports car,” said David Champion, senior director of Consumer Reports‘ Auto Test Center. “The 911 is also easy to drive, but its much less expensive Boxster sibling performed almost as well.” Here are some highlights from this month’s test group:

  • The Viper SRT is the fastest car ever tested by Consumer Reports, with a 0-60 time of 4.2 seconds.
  • The 911′s brakes rank among the best ever tested by CR. It tied with the Viper for the shortest dry stops in this group, stopping from 60 mph in just 113 feet.
  • The 911 posted the highest speed on record through CR’s emergency avoidance maneuver, at 59.5 mph.
  • The SL550 is the single most expensive car Consumer Reports has ever tested, with a base price of $94,800. As tested, the car carried a Manufacturer’s Suggested Retail Price of $105,855.
  • Full tests and ratings of the sports car group appear in the October issue of Consumer Reports, which goes on sale Tuesday, September 5.

    What Consumer Reports says:

    Consumer Reports can only recommend the Lexus SC430 from this group of vehicles. CR is unable to recommend any of the other vehicles in this month’s tests because it does not have sufficient reliability information on most of them. (Relatively few of these high-end models are sold each year.) The magazine only recommends vehicles that have performed well in its tests, have at least average predicted reliability based on CR’s Annual Car Reliability Survey of its own subscribers, and performed at least adequately if crash-tested or included in a government rollover test.

    The distinctive 911 is the epitome of agility and refinement in sports cars, yet it is relatively practical. The 911 Carrera S ($87,520 Manufacturer’s Suggested Retail Price as tested) is powered by a 355-hp, 3.8-liter horizontally opposed six-cylinder engine that delivers excellent acceleration and a respectable 20 mpg on premium gasoline. Its six-speed manual transmission is easy to shift and has close ratios for responsive performance. Handling is the 911′s forte. The steering is very precise with excellent feedback. The brakes rank among the best CR has ever tested.

    The Z06 Corvette was very impressive with awesome acceleration and stable, well-balanced handling. At the track, it holds its own against the Porsche 911 and Dodge Viper, though handling is less precise than the 911. The Z06 ($76,730 MSRP as tested), is equipped with a great-sounding, 505-hp, 7.0-liter V8 engine that gives it effortless acceleration at any time. It comes with a six-speed manual transmission that helps provide blazing acceleration or quiet, economical cruising. The brakes are impressive and powerful.

    In the luxury car category, the Mercedes SL nicely blends sportiness and luxury. It is comfortable and luxurious, but feels almost as fast and agile as some ultra-performance sports cars. The SL550 ($105,855 MSRP as tested) is propelled by a 382-hp, 5.5-liter V8 engine that delivers impressive acceleration—and a muted but muscular hum from the tailpipe. The new 7-speed automatic transmission is very good. But it occasionally delays downshifts or bumps abruptly into gear. Brakes bring very short stops in both wet and dry conditions.

46 COMMENTS

  1. photo
    what were you thinking?1427 days ago

    me names consumer reports queerest magazine ever

  2. photo
    Veda1427 days ago

    Yea yea… We already know that the fastest most balanced everyday car there is is a plain boring Porsche.

  3. photo
    Zan1427 days ago

    I think they are spot on, the 911 is the best sports car ever. It is what other cars should be inspired to be.

    If you do not like how it looks well I guess everyone has differant taste. I happen to hate the look of both the viper and the corvette.

    As far as the 650i, no thanks just give me an M5. More room, more power.

  4. photo
    ss1427 days ago

    ^^^ aaaaah ignorance. never been in a 911 with a capable driver huh?

  5. photo
    Jimbo – Gulph Mill$1427 days ago

    plain boring Porsche; the 911 and its relatives may look similar but they are anything but boring.
    nice job porsche, lexus, mb, bmw, and… gm.

  6. photo
    ss1427 days ago

    as for boring looks…did you look at corvette recently?

  7. photo
    Renton1427 days ago

    While the 911 may be the best all around sports car, I tend to give Consumer Reports not much cred in the sports car dept.

  8. photo
    Jimbo – Gulph Mill$1427 days ago

    lol truuu. the porsche reminds me of a bottle of goldschlagger and the corvette reminds me of a coca cola cup from mcdonalds.

  9. photo
    Mitch1427 days ago

    Id take the viper

  10. photo
    Madcapp1427 days ago

    It better be the best sports car, the’ve only been building it since the Titanic sank.

  11. photo
    1952 MG TD1427 days ago

    I think its hilarious that the 911′s brakes are notable as one of the best ever tested by them……..and the fact these great brakes tie the Viper is an afterthought.

  12. photo
    Bennifer1427 days ago

    Viper is a truck not a sports car. 911 has finess and ability something that can’t be said about the corvette

  13. photo
    Macrame Poncho1427 days ago

    1952 MG TD do you masturbate over dcx at night? Because you sure have rose tinted spectacles abut their product line.

  14. photo
    poop head1427 days ago

    the viper is a truck? wow, thats one kick ass truck! damn, i never thought a truck could break as good as a quick nimble porsche. thats amazing! man that porsche must suck ass if it can just barely beat a truck. wow.

  15. photo
    al1427 days ago

    Porsche is the closest thing there is to ferrari

  16. photo
    Witchy Woman1427 days ago

    Viper is all horsepower and no finesse or sophistication, might be good enough for you Nebraska Hicks but it isn’t good enough for me.

  17. photo
    1952 MG TD1427 days ago

    Porsche can only do so much with a rear-engined configuration. There are many negative inherent handeling traits, and the engineers in stuggart have done a comendable job minimizing these traits ofer the last 40 years… but those traits still exist. At the track, the viper is the winner of these three. on the streets, I can easily see how the viper fell behind the Z06 and 911.

  18. photo
    Harvester1427 days ago

    Fifth gear and Top gear both said the viper was complete ****

  19. photo
    ss1427 days ago

    in every test i see of these cars the 911 wins. they always say its the easiest to drive fast, or drive slow. thats why they sell so many. it can do so many diff jobs

  20. photo
    Fatstrat1427 days ago

    there is no substitute.

  21. photo
    Grindy1427 days ago

    go Porsche go

  22. photo
    British_Rover1427 days ago

    I like how after all they say about the Porsche and how great it is the only vehicle they can recomend is the Lexus SC430. Perhaps the lease sporty vehicle in the whole test.

  23. photo
    Observation1427 days ago

    The 911 is the classiest of the bunch with history to match. The C6 Vette finally has looks that match performance; was always (C4 & C5) to soft looking. Now it is a bit edgier with a hint of Ferrari design elements. The Viper was a gimic in the 90s to help Chrysler with the Dodge brand. While impressive, it lacks the lineage of it’s competitors.

  24. photo
    ss1427 days ago

    also in Autoweek a few weeks ago they did a wrap up of a 911 S long term tester. the one writer said something like “Now i understand why the guys that can afford the $30,000 over a corvette do it. Things that would be white knuckle events in a corvette are “one hand ont he wheel” events in the 911″ and the writer owned a Corvette.

  25. photo
    mblommel1427 days ago

    I doubt anyone here (including myself) has driven all 3 of these back to back so who cares what you think?

    I wonder how many posters here even have driver’s licenses?

  26. photo
    ss1427 days ago

    i have driven all three but not back to back. and it was the previous gen viper

  27. photo
    1c3d0g1427 days ago

    Pfft. I’d take a Corvette or Viper any day over that.

  28. photo
    302k mile trep1427 days ago

    pfft. i dont need leather, or a nav system, or even good handling. all i want is torque and loud exhaust. id take the viper.

  29. photo
    Ali Bongo1427 days ago

    Your choice 1c3d0g, you can waste your money any way you want its a free country

  30. photo
    Wilberforce1427 days ago

    What happens when you get to a corner 302k mile trep?

  31. photo
    302k mile trep1427 days ago

    or if i needed to show off or was on a date, then id take the vette. but if i just wanted a pure muscle machine, my pick would be the viper. the porsche, meh, its nice, but it just dosn’t have the toughness of the vette or the viper. i mean, with the quite 6cyl, the circle headlights, and the fact that its a porsche, its just not bold enough.

  32. photo
    302k mile trep1427 days ago

    the vette and the viper turn people. there not top fuel dragsters, ok. they turn. so the porsche turns a lil better, woopee. i’d still take a vette or a viper.

  33. photo
    ss1427 days ago

    302k…ill ask the same thing i asked earlier. have you ever been in a 911 with a DRIVER behind the wheel?

  34. photo
    Fatstrat1427 days ago

    we all know that Porsche has won/wins more races than anyone.
    Scoreboard.
    nuff said.

  35. photo
    Carl Jones1427 days ago

    I love Vipers, but the Porsche has the power/balance/racing pedigree. It’s the complete package.

  36. photo
    Kumbyah!1427 days ago

    I’ve never understood how anyone could be happy buying second best. But time and again on this site peopl prove that they are more than willing to spend their hard-earned on what is obviously not top drawer machinery

  37. photo
    Zan1427 days ago

    Many posters have explained themselves in their posts. Some people just want a huge loud engine.

    Some people just to not respect the more refined car and I think if you look at the majority of US made cars you notice that handling is not a major concern.

    Myself when I think about a car I am going to use on the street I do not see anything over 300BHP as being all that big of a deal, but I do want better brakes, suspension and interior refinement.

    You like what you like. Myself I prefer not to spend over 40k on a car it just seems like a waste of money.

  38. photo
    Kumbyah!1427 days ago

    dude, there aint no cornors, cornes or cones in da u.s.a

  39. photo
    JC21427 days ago

    Bennifer… the Viper is not a truck. It has NOTHING to do anything with trucks, possibly besides for the frame (is the frame from a truck?). The Viper can do fair when it comes to handling.
    And how long do you think the Porsche 911 has been around? 1964, which it was a replacement for the 356. How long has the Viper been around for? 1993? ANd it had no predeccesor, so they designed it from the floor up. Yeah, big difference in time it took to create, and price.

  40. photo
    Inspector1427 days ago

    Note that CR picked the REGULAR 911 over the Z06 and Viper.

    Not the turbo 911, but the REGULAR one.

    What a bunch of pansies. I hope everyone sees how much they’ve thrown their credibility out the window.

  41. photo
    302k mile trep1427 days ago

    ha, thats awesome. well that just proves the viper CAN turn. better than a porsche. well, with some upgrades of coarse.

  42. photo
    British_Rover1427 days ago

    JC2 The Viper engine did originall come from the V10 used in the Ram Pickups. It was just in aluminium not iron.

    The Viper does not even use a traditional frame it uses a unibody like nearly all modern vehicles do.

    The Type 911 Porsche has been redesigned over and over it is not like they are still using the same chassis from 1964 .What are you thinking? They are on the third major iteration of the type 911 design currently but they have updated it continiously over the years.

  43. photo
    Z1427 days ago

    1. The Viper has been tested against the Z06 at tracks and has been found to be slightly better in handling.
    2. The Z06 is pretty much even with the Porsche 911 Turbo in everything, but cheaper in price and interior quality.

    It all depends on what you personally prefer. The Vette and 911 are easier city-drivers than the Viper, since it’s made to be the rich man’s muscle car. The best bang-for-buck car is the Z06. And history means absolutely nothing. Your incredible racing and street history can’t change the fact that an old-fashioned pushrod engine is smacking down your state-of-the-art tubercharged flat-six.

    But even then, the Subaru Impreza has the International Engine of the Year under its hood.

  44. photo
    1c3d0g1427 days ago

    British_Rover, you have just been 0wned by Z.

  45. photo
    Bimmer1426 days ago

    Z,
    forget about Subaru winning International Engine of the Year. Just look what manufacturer won the most awards?

  46. photo
    Kendall Richardson1425 days ago

    I’m a porsche finatic literally, and all i say is that the 996 turbo needs an oil change every 40,000 miles…………

You must be logged in to post a comment.

  • REVIEW:

  • FEATURES:

  • SPECS:

  • SAFETY:

  • PRICING:


Recently Commented

  • saabaru1LeftLane has every right to limit links, they are not here to spread the love
  • jayjc08Very good article. I'm really liking the contrast between Marks more factual articles and Jacks
  • Welty RoundelI wished him well on the last post, (and was sincere) How many well wishes
  • steve333Very nice looking. However, looks don't equal driving experience. i think people are swooning over
  • rarson"It is slower then all of those cars, less equipped then most of them, and