April26
How much will it cost you to maintain the high tech bells and whistles in a modern luxury car? That’s the question asked by Kate McLeod of Forbes. Her report opens with the story of Jennifer Matthews, who had to pay $6,000 to replace navigation system in here Lexus after the dog flew into it under hard braking. And that’s just the tip of the iceberg. What happens if other delicate electronics like your rearview camera, adaptive cruise control, radar sensors or keyless systems get damaged? Replacing a rear camera, for example, is $4,000. According to the Highway Loss Data Institute, other common expensive components to replace include: Xenon headlights ($1,600), (up to $3,700), adaptive headlights ($2000), power-heated turn-signal side mirrors ($443), and reverse/parking-assists ($900).
Many of the above prices don’t include the cost of labor.
Why are some of these component so expensive? Often, it’s due to the fact that they are integrated to other systems, or modular in design. For example, cracking the glass on many Xenon headlights means the whole unit must be replace. Or, in the case of Ms. Matthews, a damaged navigation system screen meant the entire computer-screen combo had to be replaced.
But minor accidents are only part of the equation. What happens when these gadget-filled cars go out of warranty? Already, certain types of repairs to old cars end up exceeding the value of the car itself. Will delicate high-tech parts make some luxury cars worthless down the road? Maybe not, but we suspect there will be a lot of 745s with broken iDrives that never get fixed.
Which begs the question: are automakers doing enough to keep the cost of high-tech parts down, and to make replacing them easier? Recently, a consumer group accused automakers of gouging the prices for replacement digital keys. The so-called smart keys can cost between $150 and $300 to replace. Moreover, as previously mentioned, many integrated parts are expensive to repair. Should a car need a new computer just because it needs a new key? Should the navigation screen be integrated to the processing unit? Should it be impossible to replace the glass cover on Xenon headlight units? This type of manufacturing might save the automaker money at the factory, but it certainly doesn’t help consumers.
Another issue raised by McLeod is crashes. The cost of replacing airbags can be very high in minor accidents. However, the benefit of such technologies outweighs the costs associated with them. The best automakers can do is ensure these devices never deploy unless they are absolutely needed. And in recent years, they have done well in this regard.
Of course, when it comes to high repair costs, gadgets aren’t the only problem. High-tech manufacturing methods can also be very costly. In October, we cited an LA Times report that looked at BMW’s construction methods that can make for costly fender-benders.
For example, the new BMW 5-series and 6-series models are constructed with “many of the same techniques you might find at the Northrop Grumman F-18 assembly plant in El Segundo.� These new cars use rivets, epoxy adhesives and aluminum structures in the front end to save weight.
The BMW system features an aluminum firewall and aluminum frame rails that extend forward, all riveted and glued to the rest of the car’s steel structure. The entire front structure weighs just 100 pounds, giving the car a perfect 50/50 weight distribution.
Unfortunately, due to the limitations of aluminum, if the front end of one of these new Bimmers gets tweaked by more than a millimeter in a relatively light front collision, the entire front structure might need to be replaced.
The Leftlane Persprctive: In the end, technology has undoubtedly made cars much, much better. However, we think automakers could do a better job of making these gadgets easier to fix. We also think automakers should consider whether motorizing and digitizing every aspect of a car is necessary.
Kate McLeod’s article: Full report at Forbes.









That’s the price you pay in this ” Pentium with Wheels” day and age.
This is why I love the likes of Lotus, TVR and Marcos. Lesst electronics means less can go wrong.
Who really needs and of these ” Xenon headlights ($1,600), (up to $3,700), adaptive headlights ($2000), power-heated turn-signal side mirrors ($443), and reverse/parking-assists ($900). “
You can just buy a non-luxury brand car
You can just buy a non-luxury brand car less than $20k if money is the issue. Or a used car that you’re going to drive til it dies anyways.
Is there some compulsion to fix everything that is broken? Fix every luxury feature that has no impact on the drivability of the car? That’s up to the owner, who bought the car for luxury purposes.
“We also think automakers should consider whether motorizing and digitizing every aspect of a car is necessary”
So don’t buy a luxury car. There are plenty of nonmotorized, nondigitized cars out there.
Nothing to complain about. If luxury cars aren’t your taste, you do have alternatives.
How much fun will it be to have a 5-10 year old Prius?
…or worse: Escape Hybrid. I can’t imagine Ford giving a sh_t in 2011 about this now ‘old’ technology - that they only sold a few thousand of in 2006 - given that they may have been in Chap.11 since 2007..
Plan ahead; buy Toyota - whether investment grade or rolling stock.
j i m
That’s why automakers need to make cars more simple
Interesting thoughts, but I’ve appointed myself Net Policeman of improper use of the catchphrase “beg the question” — for example, its improper use in paragraph 5 of this story.
For an even-handed account of what “beg the question” is supposed to mean, and why its current degenerated usage is confusing, see:
http://www.worldwidewords.org/qa/qa-beg1.htm
Fight the improper use of “it’s”, “its”, “their”, “they’re” and “there” first. And while you’re at it, fight “aluminum” as well.
People have bought Mercedes since cars were cars. They buy top names for more car than a Corolla can give them. It just seems that in recent years that the prices of repairs have become insane. I work for a Toyota dealership in the parts department. If you lose all of your transponder keys, get ready to shell out $1000 to get your car moving again. Have a Land Cruiser with the touchscreen system? Get ready to drop $5000 to control AC and Radio again. What happens when you mess up an Avalon 3.5L engine and warranty isn’t there? $12,000 is what happens.